Your First Home vs a 95% Mortgage: Which Is Cheapest?
Getting onto the property ladder can be challenging, particularly when saving for a deposit and managing rising living costs. For first-time buyers, choosing the right purchasing route can make a considerable difference to affordability.
Two options worth exploring are the First Homes scheme and a 95% mortgage. Both aim to make homeownership more accessible, but they work differently and offer distinct financial advantages.
For buyers exploring the Manchester property market, Hunters Manchester can provide local property guidance, while property market insights in Manchester can help prospective homeowners understand local prices and available opportunities.
So, which option is actually cheaper? The answer depends on your deposit, mortgage repayments, eligibility and long-term plans.
What Is the First Homes Scheme?
The First Homes scheme is a government initiative in England designed to help eligible first-time buyers purchase a property at a discounted price.
Eligible buyers can receive a discount of at least 30% against the property’s market value. In some locations, local authorities may require discounts of 40% or 50%.
For example, a property valued at £250,000 with a 30% discount would cost £175,000.
The discount remains attached to the property when it is sold, meaning future eligible buyers can benefit from the reduced price too.
How Does a 95% Mortgage Work?
A 95% mortgage allows buyers to purchase a property with a deposit equivalent to just 5% of its purchase price.
The remaining 95% is borrowed from a mortgage lender.
For example, purchasing a £200,000 property would require:
- Deposit: £10,000.
- Mortgage: £190,000.
This can make homeownership more accessible for buyers who have sufficient income to meet mortgage affordability requirements but have limited savings.
However, borrowing a larger proportion of the property’s value generally means higher monthly repayments and potentially higher interest costs.
Comparing the Upfront Deposit Requirements
Both options can reduce the initial financial barrier to purchasing a home.
Consider a £250,000 property purchased through the First Homes scheme with a 30% discount.
| Cost | First Homes | 95% mortgage |
| Property market value | £250,000 | £250,000 |
| Purchase price | £175,000 | £250,000 |
| Deposit (5%) | £8,750 | £12,500 |
| Mortgage required | £166,250 | £237,500 |
The First Homes scheme requires a smaller deposit in this example because the purchase price is reduced.
However, the deposit percentage and mortgage product available will depend on the lender’s requirements.
Understanding the Difference in Property Prices
The most significant advantage of First Homes is the discounted purchase price.
A 30% reduction on a £250,000 property represents a saving of £75,000 against its market value.
With a conventional 95% mortgage, buyers pay the full agreed market price, although they only need a 5% deposit.
The First Homes discount can therefore provide a substantial affordability advantage, particularly in areas where property prices are relatively high.
However, buyers must remember that discounted properties come with eligibility requirements and resale restrictions.
Monthly Mortgage Repayments Compared
The amount borrowed has a direct impact on monthly mortgage repayments.
Using the previous example, assume both mortgages have a hypothetical 4.5% interest rate over 25 years.
| Mortgage | Borrowing | Approximate monthly repayment |
| First Homes | £166,250 | £924 |
| 95% mortgage | £237,500 | £1,320 |
Illustrative capital-and-interest repayments, excluding fees and other costs. Actual mortgage rates and terms will vary.
The discounted purchase price produces significantly lower repayments in this example.
It can also reduce the total interest paid over the mortgage term.
Additional Costs and Financial Considerations
The deposit and mortgage are not the only expenses to consider.
Buyers should budget for:
- Conveyancing and solicitor fees.
- Property surveys.
- Mortgage arrangement fees.
- Moving expenses.
- Buildings insurance.
- Stamp Duty Land Tax, where applicable.
First-time buyers in England may qualify for Stamp Duty relief, subject to the relevant thresholds and eligibility conditions.
First Homes purchases may also involve additional legal and administrative considerations because of the discount and resale restrictions.
Eligibility Requirements for the First Homes Scheme
Not everyone can purchase a property through the First Homes scheme.
Generally, applicants must:
- Be first-time buyers.
- Have a household income of no more than £80,000 (£90,000 in London).
- Purchase a property within the applicable price limits.
- Obtain a mortgage covering at least 50% of the discounted purchase price.
Local authorities may also prioritise applicants with a local connection or those working in particular professions.
By comparison, 95% mortgages are generally more widely accessible, although individual lenders have their own affordability, credit history and property eligibility criteria.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Each Option
First Homes scheme
Advantages:
- Discounted purchase price.
- Smaller deposit requirement in many cases.
- Lower borrowing requirements.
- Potentially more manageable monthly repayments.
Disadvantages:
- Strict eligibility criteria.
- Limited availability.
- Restrictions when selling the property.
- Less flexibility over future resale arrangements.
95% mortgage
Advantages:
- Access to a wider range of properties.
- No First Homes eligibility restrictions.
- Greater flexibility when selling.
- Suitable for buyers with smaller deposits.
Disadvantages:
- Higher mortgage borrowing.
- Potentially higher monthly repayments.
- Greater exposure to negative equity if property values fall.
- Interest costs can be substantial.
Which Option Offers Better Long-Term Value?
First Homes can offer considerable financial advantages because buyers purchase below market value.
However, the resale restrictions mean that the property cannot simply be sold at unrestricted market value. It must generally be sold to another eligible buyer with the applicable discount maintained.
A conventional 95% mortgage provides greater flexibility, although buyers take on more debt and the associated interest costs.
Your intended ownership period, financial circumstances and future plans should all influence the decision.
How Local Property Markets Influence Affordability
Property prices and availability vary significantly between locations.
In Manchester, buyers should compare the availability of discounted housing with conventional properties in their preferred neighbourhoods.
Consider transport connections, employment opportunities, local amenities and potential future demand.
A discounted property may offer excellent affordability, but its location and suitability should still meet your long-term housing requirements.
Conclusion: Which Option Is Cheapest for First-Time Buyers?
For eligible first-time buyers, the First Homes scheme will often be the cheaper option financially because of its discounted purchase price, smaller deposit and reduced mortgage borrowing.
A 95% mortgage, however, provides greater flexibility and access to a wider selection of properties.
The best choice depends on your deposit, mortgage affordability, eligibility and future plans.
Before committing, compare the total purchase costs, monthly repayments and long-term implications of both options. The cheapest route is ultimately the one that makes homeownership sustainable without placing unnecessary pressure on your finances.